Daffie
Dalayan Pious Diety
OK, before this gets too out of hand...
Yes, we can find tons of examples of buffs that perhaps need lengthening, casting time decreased, re-alignment with other classes, etc. Heck, internally we even had a slew of our own examples. The goal with this first round is to tackle some that were raid-related primarily. We have already started the bigger discussion which at some point we'll want some feedback on. Basically it incorporates a lot of what other folks have said regarding duration, SB, overwrites, etc. Before we go reviewing every single spell, we need to figure out if there will be wholesale changes to buffing. The updates made were just a step along that path.
So while I don't mind getting feedback on specific spells, please understand we probably won't do a ton with it quite yet while we decide what to do. If that bigger set of changes will be awhile coming, yeah, we'll have to start building lists of things and deciding what to do. But for now, let's hold off on adding more to the plate until we figure it out. I promise I will come ask for input when we're ready.
Totally makes sense.
Honestly, if you want to do some small QoL changes for raiding and beyond, think about looking at click buff durations at some point. Some of these durations could be made as long as regular buffs without negatively impacting the game. At any given time my paladin has ~5ish clicky buffs on. Constantly refreshing click buffs during boxing is /yawn, especially when you are boxing.
Just a sample of what I run on my tank (and honestly most of the ringer tanks I box have a very similar set up of clicky items) :
Lifetap mask click - Scream of Death (Visage of the frilakh master or I take Blades if there is a wizard)
Combine BP
AC/DS back clicky - Spikecoat (Mantle of the Forest)
DS clicky - Fire Elemental (ToLL or I use Idol of Joy if not tanking)
Vah clickies - Call to Battle (Standard of the Vah Rehn)
sometimes I use these too:
Attack - Grim Aura (Blackwatcher's Hatred)
Death Save - Death Pact (Bangle of the Devout)
Combine Legs