I applaud your post Melwin and thankyou for it!
As an officer of phoenix rising, I would also like to say that absolutely no ill feelings are felt towards any of the PR members that left us to reform Legacy or the Legacy guild as a whole. GOOD LUCK! (Grats on the Zirvane kill with 25 ppl too btw)
Unfortuantely, we had to decide on a ruling regarding PR members raiding with Legacy members.. the example you cite "raiding mobs that can drop a relic spell" was slightly out of context and was a term that was bantered about when trying to establish mobs that our members could assist smaller guilds raiding on.
Phoenix Rising wishes Legacy well and we still have a lot of mutual friends.